HomeBlogBuying Guide
Buying Guide

Cabinet Refacing vs Replacement: Which Is Right for You?

October 25, 2024 10 min read
Comparison of kitchen before and after refacing

When your kitchen cabinets need an update, you have two main options: refacing or full replacement. This guide will help you understand the differences and decide which approach is best for your Sarasota home.

See What Refacing Would Look Like
Preview your kitchen transformation with our free AI tool

What is Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing involves keeping your existing cabinet boxes and replacing only the visible components: doors, drawer fronts, and hardware. A matching veneer is applied to exposed cabinet frames, giving your kitchen a completely new look without the cost and disruption of full replacement.

What is Cabinet Replacement?

Cabinet replacement means removing all existing cabinets and installing entirely new ones. This allows for complete layout changes but involves more extensive work including potential modifications to plumbing, electrical, and walls.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorRefacingReplacement
Cost$8,000 - $20,000$20,000 - $60,000+
Timeline3-5 days4-8 weeks
DisruptionMinimalSignificant
Layout ChangesNot possibleFully customizable
Interior QualityKeeps existingAll new
Permits NeededUsually noneOften required

Choose Refacing If...

Your cabinet boxes are structurally sound
You're happy with your current kitchen layout
You want to minimize disruption and mess
You're working with a tighter budget
You need a quick turnaround
Your cabinets are less than 20 years old

Choose Replacement If...

Your cabinet boxes are damaged, warped, or deteriorating
You want to change your kitchen layout significantly
You need to modify plumbing or electrical locations
Your cabinets are very old with outdated construction
You have water damage affecting cabinet structure
You're doing a complete gut renovation anyway

When Refacing Won't Work

Be aware that refacing isn't suitable in every situation:

Cabinet boxes have water damage or structural issues
Particleboard cabinets that are delaminating
You want to add or remove cabinets significantly
Current cabinets have non-standard dimensions

The Bottom Line

For most Sarasota homeowners with cabinets in decent structural condition, refacing offers the best value. You get a dramatic transformation at roughly half the cost and a fraction of the time. However, if your cabinets are failing or you need major layout changes, replacement may be the better long-term investment.

The best way to know which option is right for you? Get a professional assessment. A reputable cabinet refacing company will honestly tell you if your cabinets are good candidates for refacing or if replacement would be more appropriate.

Related Articles

Wondering about costs? Check out our comprehensive Cabinet Refacing Cost Guide for Sarasota 2024.

Looking for style inspiration? Read our guide on the Best Cabinet Styles for Florida Coastal Homes.

Service Areas

We provide cabinet refacing services throughout Sarasota County. Visit our homepage for more information, or explore our local service areas: Lakewood Ranch, Longboat Key, Palmer Ranch, and Bradenton.

Leaning Toward Refacing?

See exactly what your kitchen could look like with new cabinet doors and colors.

Try Visualizer

Get Expert Advice

Schedule a free consultation and we'll assess your cabinets and recommend the best approach.

Get Free Assessment